About Us

A long long time ago my father Matteo was the first of his large family to move from Sicily to New York to live the American dream. My father was a baker in Brooklyn where I was born. We moved to Long Island where my father opened up his first Pizzeria in Riverhead New York. Over the years his business grew to 15 pizzerias throughout New York. I learned to be a pizzaiolo from my father & my older brother Giuseppe. Today I am the last of five brothers to carry on my father’s tradition, using his same recipe & technique to make NY style pizza πŸ•

This is a picture of my dads first pizza shop. My mother is standing out front while my father is making pizza in the window. Notice the $.25 cents a slice, how times have changed!

Cheese Calzone
Cheese Pizza
Meatball Parmigiana
Pepperoni Pizza

Contact Form

Brooklyn Pizza
At Brooklyn Pizza in Powell, we serve Pizza and a variety of other classics such as our Pesto Chicken Pizza, Meatball Parm Sandwich, and Pepperoni Roll . We are located on N Liberty St just a few minutes from Adventure Park. Order Online for carryout today!
Cuisines
Pizza Calzones Italian Dessert Sandwiches
Atmosphere
Casual Dining
Food Types
Vegetarian Options
Service Options
Free Parking Has TV Outdoor Seating
Business Hours
Mon: Closed
Tue - Sun: Noon - 8:00 PM
Carryout Hours
Mon: Closed
Tue - Sun: Noon - 7:15 PM

Testimonials
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

Top notch pizza. Best New York pizza around. The staff is amazing! Nice to have a place you can get a whole pie or just a slice. I've recommended Brooklyn to all my work friends and we always make a stop when in the area. Great size slices πŸ‘Œ. Keep making the best pie around!

-M Thompson

β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

Outstanding taste, crunchy, and everything you would think a NY slice tastes like. Walk in and buy it by the slice makes it awesome for people like me on the run. Kudos to this pizza joint, y’all make a great pizza.

-James B.

β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

Tastes like I stepped off of the Subway in Brooklyn and had a slice! This is authentic NY pizza… perfect fold, right amount of delicious cheese. I ate a slice in the parking lot, then had to pull over 3 miles later for another! Get the sausage and thank me later

-glasspumpkin73